At odds in a spritely woodland
(clop clop clop clop clop clop)
MAMAAA! I-A IN DA PLAYROOM! DEY GOT RHINOCEROS!
(clop clop clop clop clop clop)
(repeat)
As we walk into the main lodge dining room Evan breaks into a run, eager to get to the toys, and I call out to him in my best I-love-you-but-I-mean-business voice Evan, no running please.
Yes, says the lady at the front desk, eyeing me sternly. You absolutely MUST stop these children from running. We have had complaints.
I smile meekly and nod my head, shamed, and retreat to the library to nurse Ben. As I’m sitting there, a crotchety old fart an elderly gentleman walks up to the front desk and says to the lady
Those damn kids had better not be running around tonight. I don’t like it. You’d better sort out those people, and tell them to control their children.
She doesn’t know I’m in earshot. She wags her head up and down earnestly in shared aggravation and says
Oh, I know, I just spoke with one of them, and boy, I sure do hope they DO SOMETHING. It’s not right, those kids just running around like that. Let’s hope they’re decent people and they get those children in control of themselves.
After Ben was done I walked up the desk, fuming, and said to her, "Look — we’re doing the best we can. We have six kids under the age of three, and we are guiding them constantly. If we’re not welcome, you just let me know. But this has always been a place for families, since I was their age and for longer. We have to eat, for chrissakes. It’s not like we can duct tape their ankles together. I’ve tried. They wiggle too much."
What is it, this pariah-hood that comes alongside parenthood?
The constant hairy eyeballs shot our way, the shaking of the heads, the underhanded, judging public commentary.
It hit me badly, came near to souring what was a glorious weekend.
I have left my baby son here, I almost wanted to say. Don’t you dare make me feel like I’ve made a mistake.
And defensive, so defensive right now. The inadequacy of two — feeling like I am incapable of handling the baby plus a headstrong, wandering Evan. And the guilt of the shadow of three — feeling I would have completely fallen apart trying to handle two babies plus a headstrong, wandering Evan.
And what follows from that? An implied progression to relief, which isn’t what I feel, because I’d give anything… but the proximity of the sensation disgusts me. Cue further self-loathing.
Too close to the surface, Ben joggling in the mei tai, dragging Evan by one arm as he screeches I WANT MY DADDY! in a tangled, furious heap on the ground, breaking away sporadically for the opposite direction, or oncoming traffic, or pondfuls of sharks with fricking laser beams attached to their foreheads.
(You know, whatever strikes his fancy and/or is the antithesis of what I have the time or inclination to indulge.)
On top of this, when we’re all trying the best we can, baring our souls and guts and hearts wide open in front of all the world, you revoke your welcome.
You, who were once somebody’s baby. Or perhaps not. Perhaps you sprang from betwixt your mama’s legs clutching a bottle of geritol and a bottomless well of complaints and a righteous resentment of exuberance that doesn’t include you.
Not that all seniors are fist-shaking, jowl-jiggling, black-sock-and-sandal-wearing tyrants. Joe Public takes on a limitless array of personas, clucking disapprovingly at the disturbance to his peace caused by us breeders and our snot-nosed hooligan offspring.
We’re here because I grew up coming here every summer, back when it was wall-to-wall families, raucous and loving and wild, all sandy feet and sun-kissed tousledness. This place is special to us, all woodsmokey and crisp and kitschy-rustic.
It’s where we chose to lay our son to rest, under a gnarly tree in everglade waters accessible only to canoes and woodland sprites.
This past weekend we enticed much of Justin’s extended family to come with us, four families in all, and five toddlers, and one thriving baby. We were so touched they made the trek, and the kids took to it like a dream, delighted.
For breakfasts and suppers we took over two large tables near the entrance, at the main lodge, as close as possible to a playroom ordained by the lord of fisher price himself.
As cabin neighbours appeared Evan would turn in his seat to say “Hey LADY! I gotta DINOSAUR! My name is EFFAN! I am SEVEN!” and for the most part, folk were wonderfully chatty back to him, my rollicking, panting, I-love-the-whole-wide-world golden retriever of a son.
Then “I-all DONE!” and down he’d go with his cousins, all of them wearing a trail in the wood floor between the table and the toys.
Not tantruming, not yelling, just gleeful, rosy-cheeked, back and forth, with us parents being as considerate and as mindful as we can. Just as it was when I was a kid — minus the disapproval.
Next time, we’re bringing all the cousins — and thicker skin. Consider yourself warned. Because it's our place too, more so now than we ever thought it could be, and more than you could ever possibly imagine.
+++++++++
I saw it from a distance, unsure, a flash of white.
Walked to it through the stream in my wellies, reached into the tannin-rich water to grasp the top neck of Liam’s urn, drifted. Cracked off the last time we were here by Justin’s leatherman as I looked on, and then looked away.
I held it for a while, cool and slick with water, sitting on a log under his keeper-tree as the creek bubbled and swirled around my boots. The bright openness of the urn’s mouth lay under the surface where I sat, a match to the ceramic plug that I held in my palm.
I hesitated but then placed it back under the water next to the urn, pressed it gently into the pebbles as if planting a seed. Then stood up and thought it was just something that held him for a while, that’s all. It belongs here.
As we paddled away from this beauty he followed us from high above on the breeze, watching as his mother and father’s bright red canoe weaved through the lilypads, brown and curling dry with the coming autumn.


Reader Comments (61)
People like that deserve to be told off if they forget so easily what being a child is like.
If I ever get so humourless, I hope I'm dead. Children are people too, and at the very least they don't smell like Ben Gay.
There is a difference between exuberance and rambunctiousness.
Ha- and being a mom of a two-and-a-halfer, I relate. My newest is about 6 weeks now, and in public I am one handed and terrified (one screaming hungry and the other gleefully prancing off just out of reach). Oh for those extra hands that could come out of nowhere at the right time to give relief!
The last section, about visiting Liam's place was so hard to read and I'm not sure why. Thank you for continuing to share those moments with us.
What I've noticed is that while everyone thinks my 11 month old is precious and adorable, they view my imaginative, sweet 3 year old as unruly and undisciplined. I guess because she speaks? AND questions the world around her?
The "children should be seen and not heard" is a ridiculous notion but it appears crotchity seniors and many mid-lifers believe in it.
Sadly, people forget just how precious each tiny soul is and that we never know how long we will have them.
I'm smiling through tears at the laser beaming sharks. They're always waiting in the wings around here, too.
In the face of those tsking, scowling busybodies, I TRY to remind myself that the negative people are always more vocal than the admiring, appreciative strangers. (But if you find a magic skin thickening potion, puhleeeze send me that website too!)
Your weekend sounds like it was lovely.
xo
The lodge shouldn't have a playroom next to the dining room if they don't want to hear the wonderful sound of running feet. It sounds like your Evan has a wonderful ability to live life. We adults should look at children and try to live as they do. Good for you for speaking your mind to the old lady at the desk :)
I can't imagine how your heart felt when you saw Liam's urn. Hugs to you from South Carolina.
Much love,ashley
Just the other morning, at our local bagel shop, I and two girlfriends wrestled our seven kids into the place and sat. The kids, all under the age of 4.5, did amazingly well, but there was some dancing. At one point, an elderly lady 'shooed' them away from her table, where they'd wandered (like four feet away from us, and for about 30 seconds), shot them and us knife-point looks, and talked under her breath to her friend about how kids today are so 'wild.'
Hot damn lady, you don't know the half of it. I am the first parent out there to fear for the future of our children; I'm a former teacher, a veteran from the front-lines of 'kids today.' There is drugs and sex-too-young and too many parents who truly don't give a sh**, sadly, about their children. That's categorically WILD.
But a bit of happy dancing on a sunny Tuesday morning - hardly a reason to shudder; and for you, Kate, and the weekend trek you all took to your most beloved place: spread the happiness, sweet Effin-boy, bleed it into their hearts. I hope to never lose my sense of spirit as I grow older. There's a line between rowdy plate-throwing behavior and a little boy running down the hallway towards a toy room, for crying out loud.
Go back and live it up; make it yours forever; perhaps write a letter to someone important there, and tell him how important the place is to your family - a home away from home, of sorts, in so many ways they couldn't imagine.
You are always what I need right when I read you. Thanks for sharing this post -
As for people who are intolerant of children, it still gets to me too. This weekend we took the kids to brunch in a restaurant I frequent often, but not usually with children. Most people were charmed, but there were a few stares.... It's hard not to feel inadequate when you feel that judgmental gaze.
As for the whole wild toddler thing, I have an opposite story that filled my heart this week. We flew from Glasgow to Toronto (7.5 hours) and D slept for a total of 20 minutes. He spent the rest of the time running up and down the aisle of the plane and kept bumping into peoples knees. I felt horrible, but any attempt to restrain him in his seat met with a complete meltdown - he's just not able physically sit still for that long. So we took turns walking behind him and apologizing and met with nothing but friendly smiles. It was amazing to meet so many non-judgemental people who laughed with my son and understood what it was like to be his age. Some people suck, but as a whole, most people rock.
I was reading through your archives the other day (busybody, stalker that I am) and came to post where you linked to a salon article (where a woman talked candidly of sex after childbirth). The comments following that post were AWFUL - particularly one which was headed 'BREEDER' which more or less accused those of having kids as being stupid and deliberately self-destructive....it finished by saying that we (breeders) should just get out of the way. (I don't know where this person is headed in such a hurry.....down the asset-rich path of oblivion and exctinction, I guess)
Anyway - sorry for the long, incoherent ramble - I'm just reeling with shock at the moment that there really are people who think children are just a nuisance.
I am in shock that Liam's urn waited for you. My questions about the afterlife are answered, continually, by Liam. And I thank him for that gift.
Those people? That said those things? As a server, I wait on them every day. And they help me to embrace the joy that is my life, my children. And I thank God, Goddess, Buddha (I'm still trying to figure that one out), that I am not like them.
And it soothes me.
As for the grumpy dried prunes: maybe someone should gently point out to them that without all those boisterous toddlers, there won't be anyone around to take care of them in their dotage.
One of the things I loved the most about traveling around Europe with our 16 month toddler this summer was the complete difference in attitudes: in Italy or Eastern Europe, kids are seen not as a nuisance, but as...pets. Fellow diners smiled and pinched C's cheeks, waiters brought over special treats (he ate ice cream for dinner every night), and everyone indulged him. And no one pursed their lips in sour disapproval.
i want to shake it off, for you, that intrusion of judgement and petty crabbiness into the place you chose for Liam, that place they are too ignorant to realize will never be theirs, at least to you, no matter how much righteousness they try to exert.
i try to smite them from over here. just out of an overflowing heart, and a little twist of joy that you found the urn, the trace, the tangible...
Ashley: "The lodge shouldn't have a playroom next to the dining room if they don't want to hear the wonderful sound of running feet..." - well put.
And Trish, I love that story. Your point - that most people don't mind the cacaphony of kids in public (within reason) - has another side, I think.
I'm sure there are parents out there who don't check their kids enough in public - but just now, trying to think of what I've personally witnessed, the vast majority of parents I've witnessed have a decent sense of when it's time to lay down the law (or leave, or take some other drastic measures). They seem aware of their own potential for mayhem, and do their best to curb it, to smile, to consider their environment and other people.
Makes me wonder if the whole notion of chronically uncontrolled kids is an urban myth, a random complaint that's turned into a generalization.
Or maybe what I've seen doesn't represent the norm, happily enough...
you say "it belongs here" - true - but still i don't know if i could have put it back.
i know i don't know you (which makes me feel a little strange saying this), but reading this post i was just overcome with a feeling of pride at the amazing job you are doing.
I have 4 kids, ages 8,6,2 and 7 months, so I have had my fair share of "hairy eyeball" experiences, but somehow those aren't the ones that stick with me. Every once in a while, some kind stranger goes out of there way to let me know I'm doing ok, and those are the ones that I remember. We were in church one Sunday before my youngest was born. I was wrestling with 2 older, whinier, ones who would have rather been anywhere else, and a spirited crawler. Church always seems some sort of torture, and I rarely pay it the attention it warrants, and that day by the end I was exhausted. We were getting ready to leave, and the woman behind us stopped me and said, "You have a beautiful family. You should be very proud." I wanted to weep. But I will never forget it.
So this is a longwinded way of saying that I hope that the majority of people we meet are of the kinder variety. Try (while difficult, I know) to let the nasty ones roll off without a second thought. You are an amazing and inspiring Mother. As long as you are writing, I'll be here reading.
I love having lisping jabbering toddler conversations. The things kids say. I feel sorry for anyone that can't enjoy kids and their innocence and exuberance. What a dreary life they must lead.
If only people would offer to help, instead of judge.
So altogether, our group was six kids - five of them toddlers, plus one baby.
My 3 year old is all over the place at times and so we've developed a little *game* where she pretends to be 'Lucky' the dog and I'm the owner. I will then use our dog's leash and attach it to a belt loop and on we go with my toddler boys in their stroller. She loves it and will often request playing this game at home. Whilst playing this game I always get a few raised eyebrows but at least I'm able to keep my 3 kids safe. The moms who pass me by (usually) smile at my craftiness.
Your last paragraphs are so amazing, what a beautiful and sacred place to viset and honour your son.
Kate, you're so brave. I feel so fragile after reading the last paragraph. You ended your journey so gracefully through the pads. It seems like the perfect place for Liam to rest.*
When Andrew and I visited MH, it was so lovely. I can't imagine bringing Molly there and getting the same comments from old coots like that. I love what you said to that woman and please, tell us what she said back. The staff seemed so friendly, but then, Molly was still hanging out inside the belly.I'm so glad you had a lovely time there with all the kids, and one day I hope we can come with. And if we do, I'm going to take Molly to the main lodge and give her the lids from pots and pans just to liven up the place even more ;)
I much prefer the ones whose eyes get moist with remembrance and longing when they see small children.
***we took the pnut to mass sunday- the one that is held downstairs where she can run around in the back and not bother as many people as she would upstairs in a more formal setting. i always go back and forth between respecting other's experiences and trying to contain my kid so as to not bother them and just letting go of my anxiety and letting her do her thing. anyway after mass the priest came up to us and i immediately started apologizing for her antics and he said- "i almost laughed up on the altar b/c my little nephew has a thing for wearing sunglasses indoors also!" what a nice guy. afterwards my husband said maybe we should have suggested she would have been more calm with a shorter sermon. ah well. glad you stood your ground.